IRS Announces the 2005 Dirty Dozen
The Internal Revenue Service has unveiled its annual listing of notorious tax
scams, the “Dirty Dozen,” reminding taxpayers to be wary of schemes that promise
to eliminate taxes or otherwise sound too good to be true.
The “Dirty Dozen” for 2005 includes several new scams that either manipulate
laws governing charitable groups, abuse credit counseling services or rely on
refuted arguments to claim tax exemptions. The agency also sees the continuing
spread of identity theft schemes preying on people through e-mail, the Internet
or the phone, sometimes with con artists posing as representatives of the IRS.
“The Dirty Dozen is a reminder that tax scams can take many forms,” IRS
Commissioner Mark W. Everson said. “Don’t be fooled by false promises peddled by
scam artists. They’ll take your money and leave you with a hefty tax bill.”
Involvement with tax schemes can lead to imprisonment and fines. The IRS
routinely pursues and shuts down promoters of these scams. But taxpayers should
also remember that anyone pulled into these schemes can face repayment of taxes
plus interest and penalties.
Persons who suspect tax fraud can call the IRS at 1-800-829-0433.
The Dirty Dozen
The IRS urges people to avoid these common schemes:
1. Trust Misuse. Unscrupulous promoters for years have urged taxpayers
to transfer assets into trusts. They promise reduction of income subject to tax,
deductions for personal expenses and reduced estate or gift taxes. However, some
trusts do not deliver the promised tax benefits, and the IRS is actively
examining these arrangements. More than two dozen injunctions have been obtained
against promoters since 2001, and numerous promoters and their clients have been
prosecuted. As with other arrangements, taxpayers should seek the advice of a
trusted professional before entering into a trust.
2. Frivolous Arguments. Promoters have been known to make the
following outlandish claims: that the Sixteenth Amendment concerning
congressional power to lay and collect income taxes was never ratified; that
wages are not income; that filing a return and paying taxes are merely
voluntary; and that being required to file Form 1040 violates the Fifth
Amendment right against self-incrimination or the Fourth Amendment right to
privacy. Don’t believe these or other similar claims. Such arguments are false
and have been thrown out of court. While taxpayers have the right to contest
their tax liabilities in court, no one has the right to disobey the law.
3. Return Preparer Fraud. Dishonest return preparers can cause many
headaches for taxpayers who fall victim to their ploys. Such preparers derive
financial gain by skimming a portion of their clients’ refunds and charging
inflated fees for return preparation services. They attract new clients by
promising large refunds. Taxpayers should choose carefully when hiring a tax
preparer. As the saying goes, if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
No matter who prepares the return, the taxpayer is ultimately responsible for
its accuracy. Since 2002, the courts have issued injunctions ordering dozens of
individuals to cease preparing returns, and the Department of Justice has filed
complaints against dozens of others, which are pending in court.
4. Credit Counseling Agencies. Taxpayers should be careful with credit
counseling organizations that claim they can fix credit ratings, push debt
payment agreements or charge high fees, monthly service charges or mandatory
“contributions” that may add to debt. The IRS Tax Exempt and Government Entities
Division has made auditing credit counseling organizations a priority because
some of these tax-exempt organizations, which are intended to provide education
to low-income customers with debt problems, are charging debtors large fees,
while providing little or no counseling.
5. "Claim of Right" Doctrine. In this scheme, a taxpayer files a
return and attempts to take a deduction equal to the entire amount of his or her
wages. The promoter advises the taxpayer to label the deduction as “a necessary
expense for the production of income” or “compensation for personal services
actually rendered.” This so-called deduction is based on a misinterpretation of
the Internal Revenue Code and has no basis in law.
6. “No Gain” Deduction. Similar to “Claim of Right,” filers attempt to
eliminate their entire adjusted gross income (AGI) by deducting it on Schedule
A. The filer lists his or her AGI under the Schedule A section labeled “Other
Miscellaneous Deductions” and attaches a statement to the return, referring to
court documents and including the words “No Gain Realized.”
7. Corporation Sole. Since September 2004, the Department of Justice
has obtained six injunctions against promoters of this scheme and filed
complaints against 11 others. Participants apply for incorporation under the
pretext of being a “bishop” or “overseer” of a one-person, phony religious
organization or society with the idea that this entitles the individual to
exemption from federal income taxes as a nonprofit, religious organization. When
used as intended, Corporation Sole statutes enable religious leaders to separate
themselves legally from the control and ownership of church assets. But the
rules have been twisted at seminars where taxpayers are charged fees of $1,000
or more and incorrectly told that Corporation Sole laws provide a “legal” way to
escape paying federal income taxes, child support and other personal debts.
8. Identity Theft. It pays to be choosy when it comes to disclosing
personal information. Identity thieves have used stolen personal data to access
financial accounts, run up charges on credit cards and apply for new loans. The
IRS is aware of several identity theft scams involving taxes. In one case,
fraudsters sent bank customers fictitious correspondence and IRS forms in an
attempt to trick them into disclosing their personal financial data. In another,
abusive tax preparers used clients’ Social Security numbers and other
information to file false tax returns without the clients’ knowledge. Sometimes
scammers pose as the IRS itself. Last year the IRS shut down a scheme in which
perpetrators used e-mail to announce to unsuspecting taxpayers that they were
“under audit” and could set matters right by divulging sensitive financial
information on an official-looking Web site. Taxpayers should note the IRS does
not use e-mail to contact them about issues related to their accounts. If
taxpayers have any doubt whether a contact from the IRS is authentic, they can
call 1-800-829-1040 to confirm it.
9. Abuse of Charitable Organizations and Deductions. The IRS has
observed an increase in the use of tax-exempt organizations to improperly shield
income or assets from taxation. This can occur, for example, when a taxpayer
moves assets or income to a tax-exempt supporting organization or donor-advised
fund but maintains control over the assets or income, thereby obtaining a tax
deduction without transferring a commensurate benefit to charity. A
“contribution” of a historic facade easement to a tax-exempt conservation
organization is another example. In many cases, local historic preservation laws
already prohibit alteration of the home’s facade, making the contributed
easement superfluous. Even if the facade could be altered, the deduction claimed
for the easement contribution may far exceed the easement’s impact on the value
of the property.
10. Offshore Transactions. Despite a crackdown on the practice by the
IRS and state tax agencies, individuals continue to try to avoid U.S. taxes by
illegally hiding income in offshore bank and brokerage accounts or using
offshore credit cards, wire transfers, foreign trusts, employee leasing schemes,
private annuities or life insurance to do so. The IRS, along with the tax
agencies of U.S. states and possessions, continues to aggressively pursue
taxpayers and promoters involved in such abusive transactions.
11. Zero Return. Promoters instruct taxpayers to enter all zeros on
their federal income tax filings. In a twist on this scheme, filers enter zero
income, report their withholding and then write “nunc pro tunc” –– Latin for
“now for then” –– on the return.
12. Employment Tax Evasion. The IRS has seen a number of illegal
schemes that instruct employers not to withhold federal income tax or other
employment taxes from wages paid to their employees. Such advice is based on an
incorrect interpretation of Section 861 and other parts of the tax law and has
been refuted in court. Recent cases have resulted in criminal convictions, and
the courts have issued injunctions against more than a dozen persons ordering
them to stop promoting the scheme. Employer participants can also be held
responsible for back payments of employment taxes, plus penalties and interest.
It is worth noting that employees who have nothing withheld from their wages are
still responsible for payment of their personal taxes.
Other Scams Still Lingering
The IRS removed four scams from the Dirty Dozen this year: slavery
reparations, improper home-based businesses, the Americans with Disabilities Act
and EITC dependent sharing. The agency has noticed declines in activity in some
of these schemes. But taxpayers should remain wary because the IRS has seen old
scams resurface or evolve.
Moreover, the IRS reminds taxpayers to be vigilant about cons that may not be
on the Dirty Dozen list. New tax scams or schemes routinely pop up, especially
around tax time.
|