There are amusing and horrific stories of the trials and
tribulations associated with the transfer of technology, and the implementation
of new systems and architecture. There are lessons that we can learn from those
who have blazed the trails before us, and those who have been burned by the
blaze. Get your fingers ready to count the five fundamental considerations for
implementing new technology.
What we learned from Oracle
"The original plan was to transition the existing IT
infrastructure to Oracle over a period of three months. It is three years later,
and we think that we are almost done with our Oracle implementation." Does this
sound familiar? if so, you have plenty of good company. Oracle is a powerful
engine. It is high octane, scalable, and has flexible object oriented
architecture to allow continuous growth and integration. So, what went wrong?
Quite often, in the eager anticipation to install the latest and
greatest engine, the other parts of the car were forgotten or overlooked. Sure
you have a powerful new engine, but your steering wheel is gone. It was replaced
by a series of point and click drop down boxes to precisely instruct the car to
turn at a specific angle. Do you want to make a 30 degree turn, a forty degree
turn, or a 90 degree turn, right or left? Simply choose the appropriate item
from the drop down menu and you will have the exact turn that you desire. Gone
is that old fashioned and inaccurate steering wheel that required manual
intervention and guidance to gradually adjust the turn in process, and installed
is the precision turning device that is managed by your mouse. The problem is,
nobody mentioned that the new steering mechanism was sold separately, and would
take another six months to program. Nobody mentioned that everyone responsible
for driving the car would have to learn a new steering methodology, lose the
ability to make manual adjustments along the way, and need to learn to be more
predictive and accurate in the selection of the accurate turn. Adjustments can
be made along the way to correct a turn, with more point and click menu
selections, if necessary. The extra time, design and development costs, and
employee training are sold separately. You see, Oracles sells that powerful
engine, not the steering wheel.
Does that sound funny or familiar? If it sounds familiar, then
the humor is bitter-sweet. If it sounds ridiculous, then you have not
experienced it yet. The steering wheel is only one example. Once the steering
mechanism is programmed and put into place, then the other discoveries begin.
That powerful engine comes with a speedometer and tachometer, so you can see
your performance and the RPM of the engine. Isn't is exciting to see that you
have only partially tapped into the incredible power of this magnificent Oracle
engine? Unfortunately, if you rely on other dashboard devices like signals for
turns, air conditioning, or a radio, then you have to build these things
yourself. After all, the engineers of the engine realize that you turn on
different roads than everyone else, you have personal preferences for your
climate controls, and you have personal preferences for terrestrial or Sirius
satellite radio stations. Therefore, you need to build the point and click
objects, men us, and radio buttons to accommodate your personal preferences, and
all the possible variations thereof. Someone forgot to mention that all of these
functions and amenities need to be custom designed for each driver.
Once the common dashboard and control devices are designed,
developed, and implemented, then the next wave of discovery begins. The old
buttons, knobs, and dials are gone. Everything has been replaced with the
convenient control of a single device, your mouse. That seemed like a wonderful
convenience when it was first described to you. All of the controls are at two
fingers on one hand. Once you are past the pain of installing all of the other
controls at additional cost, it occurs to you that it might be a little
complicated to switch between steering the car, sending a command to roll up the
windows, turning on the air conditioner, selecting a radio station, and
signaling your turn, all at the same time with one device. All of these things
require a different set of menus, so you need to choose your work stream very
carefully. Otherwise, you may run into the back of a truck while trying to turn
off the heater, and turn on Howard Stern. Just then, it begins to rain, and you
realize that the windshield wipers have not been coded yet.
Dear Larry Ellison, please forgive me if my sense of irony has
inadvertently presented what could be perceived as an unflattering commentary.
It is merely intended to make a point about proper planning for transition of
technology. After all, you do build a beautiful engine.
So, what should we do?
1) Be Aggressive
It is appropriate to be aggressive when implementing new
technology that provides a competitive edge. The competitive edge may be related
to overall system performance that empowers employees to become more productive.
A competitive edge may be a utility that empowers clients and customers to
become more self-sufficient, like installing the ATM machine outside the bank
for customer self-sufficient convenience. The competitive advantage may
integrate multiple functions, partners, or streams of data that allow for more
intelligent decisions or effective business. If the implementation, integration,
or transfer to new technology is going to have a substantial and measured
competitive advantage, then be aggressive about the pursuit of technology.
2) Be Cautious
If the transfer of technology touches upon the core competency
or revenue of your business, then be cautious about making any significant
changes. This does not mean that you avoid improving technology. It merely
implies that it is appropriate to be more cautious in studying the ramifications
and ancillary applications which may be impacted by even a subtle change to the
code. There are horror stories from companies that implemented seemingly
innocuous changes to billing, and then failed to produce invoices or statements
for the clients. During this period of the transfer of technology, revenue was
suddenly reduced. The result created financial hardship for the billing company,
and for the disgruntled customers who suddenly received several months worth of
accumulated billing once the invoicing system issues were resolved. Not only was
this an impact on cash flow during the interruption in billing, but it impacted
the relationship with the clients as well. Be aggressive about competitive
opportunities to grow your profit and performance, but be cautious when it comes
to implementing changes that may impact your core business offerings, clients,
or billing.
3) Be Quick
Be quick to implement minor changes, and carefully monitor the
impact. When it come to performance enhancement, internal suggestions for
simplifying routines, or improving the customer experience, do not delay. Design
the small changes, test the changes thoroughly, and create a schedule to
consistently roll out enhancements. Quite often, the little enhancements have
the biggest impact to business performance.
4) Be Slow
When it comes to major changes in the architecture or systems
that sustain your business, be slow in implementing change. Frequently, the core
architecture and functions of the business are the most efficient and
streamlined. The processes that get the most use are the ones that get the most
attention, and are often the most highly evolved. Unfortunately, these are also
the processes that typically are selected for the first priority when it comes
to implementing a transfer in technology. On the contrary, avoid the allure of
focusing on familiar ground, and preserve the primary processes until the
transition has been tested on some of the more complex, and less often utilized,
utilities. By focusing development on the most complex and least used functions,
there is tremendous knowledge to be gained by the experience, and the least
amount of impact to the business. There are too many horror stories of companies
that eagerly transferred the main processes, and then spent months
or years working out the bugs that could have been identified by developing a
much less needed or impactful part of the process.
5) Be Safe
There is no better time to address the vast array of potential
security needs than during the design, development, and implementation of new
technology. What personal data to you manage, process, forward, or store? This
is not limited to credit card transactions or bank account numbers for wire
transfers. Somewhere in the enormous archives of data, you are probably holding
precious private information on every one of your own employees. Employee
records contain social security numbers, bank accounts for direct deposit, names
and addresses, and possibly even reference to medical coverage. Quite often we
think about the pipeline to our customers, and forget about the goldmine of
private information inside our own facilities. Don't we owe the same protection
to our own employees?
Privacy data can include medical records, financial records, and
personal information. Driver's license numbers, credit card numbers, or even
matching email address with telephone numbers, are all potential risk to
privacy. The threat is not limited to how people access the information from the
outside, or the number of firewalls that you put into place. The threat is also
from the inside, and what kind of information is available to employees and
associates. How easy it is to look up client records and download the
information to a thumb drive? How easy is it to copy the entire company database
of customer information, account information, or intellectual property? What
would it be worth to a disgruntled employee to take valuable client information
to a competitor?
There is no better time than the present to have a security
expert evaluate the potential breaches of privacy in your organization. If you
have customers, credits cards, customer accounts, client information,
intellectual property, financial information, medical information, or employee
information stored electronically, accessible on a network, or printed in files,
then it is time to consider security.
If you are in the midst of preparing for a technology
transformation, design, development, integration, or implementation, then it is
the perfect time to review all of the related documents with a security and
privacy expert. If you are organizing all of this information, then why not take
advantage of your efforts to protect your customers, your employees, and your
business? Executives and management are increasingly being held responsible for
ignoring or overlooking the potential security breaches in their respective
organizations, both from protecting customers from external threats, and for
controlling the actions of disgruntled employees. Mitigate risk to the company,
and the executives of the company, by taking appropriate and reasonable
precautions for expert analysis, controls, and privacy.
Words of Wisdom
"Technology is dominated by two types of people: those who
understand what they do not manage, and those who manage what they do not
understand."
- Putt's Law
"For a list of all the ways technology has failed to improve the
quality of life, please press three."
- Alice Kahn
"There is an evil tendency underlying all our technology - the
tendency to do what is reasonable even when it isn't any good."
- Robert Pirsig
"Humanity is acquiring all the right technology for all the
wrong reasons."
- R. Buckminster Fuller
John Mehrmann is a freelance author, industry expert and
President of Executive Blueprints Inc., an organization devoted to improving
business practices and developing human capital.
www.ExecutiveBlueprints.com provides free resource materials for trainers,
sample Case Studies, educational articles and references to local affiliates for
consulting and executive coaching. Contact the author at
JohnM@ExecutiveBlueprints.com
or (877) 290-2503.